- Nick Allegretti
- Mike Caliendo
- Drew Tranquill
- Jon Feliciano
- Corey Luciano - Practice Squad
- Nick Bosa
: Known for his success as a head coach in the NFL, Bill Parcells has Italian roots. He coached the New York Giants to two Super Bowl victories in the 1986 and 1990 seasons (Super Bowls XXI and XXV). Parcells is highly respected for his coaching prowess and has left a lasting legacy in the league.
: Known as "Goose," Tony Siragusa was a prominent defensive tackle in the NFL, playing a key role in the Baltimore Ravens' defense during their Super Bowl XXXV victory in 2001. After retiring, Siragusa became a well-known television personality and football analyst.
: While not of Italian descent himself, Tony Dungy has strong ties to the Italian-American community through his marriage. Dungy made history as the first African-American head coach to win a Super Bowl when he led the Indianapolis Colts to victory in Super Bowl XLI in 2007.